Magnolia Bakery Reviews

Magnolia Bakery has an overall rating of 4.7 based on 26 reviews. Customer feedback on Magnolia Bakery is mixed: Magnolia Bakery reviewers highlight positive aspects like delicious baked goods, friendly customer service, cozy atmosphere, great variety of treats, which strongly appeal to food enthusiasts, families, dessert lovers, local community members. However, Magnolia Bakery is often criticized for its higher prices, long wait times, limited seating, inconsistent product availability.

4.7/5.0

26 reviews

5 Stars

18

4 Stars

3

3 Stars

2

2 Stars

0

1 Star

0

All Magnolia Bakery Reviews (26)
debra.Holloway
May 26, 2026
"Way easier than waiting in line"
I ordered from Magnolia Bakery online it was such a smooth process. Checkout was simple, payment went through with no random extra steps, and my order was ready right at the pickup time I picked. While other people were waiting around, I just gave the staff my name and they handed it over quickly. Super easy and definitely the way I’d order again.
wesley.Canterbury
May 26, 2026
"Super easy to get to"
It was right near the subway, so I found it really quickly and did not have any hassle getting there.
DianeAnger_46
May 23, 2026
"Wish I Had Ordered Sooner"
Everything arrived perfectly, i kind of regret not getting it sooner. The whole experience was smooth, and I’m really happy with it
hello_carl936
May 06, 2026
"Super easy to order with my allergy!!!"
I have a food allergy, so ordering can be kind of stressful, but the allergen notes made it way easier!!! I felt like I could actually choose what I wanted without worrying the whole time!!!
Norman_smith70
May 05, 2026
"I ordered from Magnolia Bakery and thought it…"
I ordered from Magnolia Bakery and thought it was really good overall. The banana pudding was rich, but not in that over-the-top sugary way, which I really appreciated. Is it just me, or is that kind of balance hard to find with desserts? The cupcakes were a bit sweeter than what I usually go for, but they were still nice with coffee. Shipping was totally fine too. I’m giving it 4 stars because one item was just a little too sweet for my taste, but I’d still order again
charlesoakden4913
April 28, 2026
"Portions were bigger than I thought"
I ordered a few cupcakes and some banana pudding from Magnolia Bakery, the portions surprised me. In a good way. The pudding cup looked kind of small online, but once I started eating it, it was actually filling. Couldn’t even finish it all at once.

The cupcakes were a decent size too. Not those tiny “fancy bakery” ones that are gone in two bites. Felt like I actually got my money’s worth, which doesn’t happen much lately. Definitely would order again when I’m craving a real sweet treat.
Mildred_landers05
April 19, 2026
"Super cute packaging tbh"
The box looked really cute and everything was packed so neatly. it came looking great lol.
william2003
April 16, 2026
"They did help me out, but the…"
They did help me out, but the replies took a bit longer than I expected.
ThomasAngelico
April 04, 2026
"Soft and Moist"
I went with my gut on this one, and I’m glad I did. It turned out really moist with a nice soft texture, exactly what I was hoping for.
HOLT
March 26, 2026
"I’ll be honest, when I first saw the..."
I’ll be honest, when I first saw the line at Magnolia Bakery I was like… oh no, this might take a while. But it actually moved way quicker than I expected. The staff seemed to have a good rhythm going, so it never felt like we were just stuck there doing nothing.
I think I waited maybe 10 or 15 minutes, which felt reasonable considering how busy it was. The line was easy to figure out, nobody looked lost or confused, and yeah, overall it was a smooth stop
hello_catherine339
March 24, 2026
"Exactly what I needed"
Got exactly what I asked for, no fuss at all. Really happy with it, thnaks!
hello_rachel444
March 21, 2026
"Clean shop, just caught it at a weird time"
I stopped in at what was probably just bad timing, maybe between rushes or while they were restocking, but the place itself was really clean. The counters were tidy, the floors looked good, and everything felt well taken care of. Even with my timing being a little off, the shop made a solid impression.
james_Clark94
March 21, 2026
"I ordered a few cupcakes and some banana…"
I ordered a few cupcakes and some banana pudding for pickup, and shockingly enough, everything was correct. No missing items, the flavors actually matched what I picked online, and it was ready when I got there. So yeah, simple, no issues, which shouldn’t feel like a win but here we are
SMITH
March 01, 2026
"Magnolia Bakery has sooo many different treats…"
Magnolia Bakery has sooo many different treats to choose from!!! Cupcakes, banana pudding, cakes, cookies... it was hard to decide lol!!! Everything looked super fresh, and there was something for everyone in my family, which made it even better!!! Really happy with all the options and I’ll definitely be ordering again!!!
jamesglazier6773
January 23, 2026
"Fresh and totally worth it"
I ordered from Magnolia Bakery i was really happy with it. The cupcakes were soft, the frosting didn’t taste stale or weirdly heavy, and the banana pudding showed up still chilled and creamy. Say what you want, but you can definitely tell when desserts have been sitting around too long, and this didn’t feel like that at all. I’d definitely order again when I’m craving something sweet.
PhilipPollack_27
January 18, 2026
"Still good every time"
I’ve ordered from Magnolia Bakery a few times now, it’s been good every single time. Say what you want, but the banana pudding always tastes the same, and that’s exactly why I keep going back.
Pickup has always been easy for me, and my online orders have been ready when they said they would be. It’s not some complicated thing to explain, they’re just consistent, and I haven’t had a bad visit yet.
carlie2004
January 12, 2026
"Cute Spot, If You Enjoy Dodging People"
The place is really cute and has that charming old-school bakery vibe, which I liked. That said, it was packed and loud when I went, so not exactly the peaceful little bakery moment I apparently thought I was walking into. Great for a quick stop, but I wouldn’t plan on hanging out there too long unless you find crowds relaxing for some reason.
Rosella_sinn05
January 07, 2026
"Really good cupcakes, honestly"
I got the banana pudding and some cupcakes, and good they were, honestly. The pudding was super creamy, and the cupcakes had a nice flavor without being too sweet. Everything tasted fresh to me. I’d definitely order again
james_Bellamy96
January 02, 2026
"Good Cake, Checkout Could Be Smoother"
The cake was really good, so no complaints there. Ordering was fine overall, but the checkout process felt more annoying than it needed to be. Delivery also took a bit longer than I expected, but at least the cake was worth it in the end.
janice.Barry
December 28, 2025
"Sooo glad they had what I needed"
I checked the site for a super last minute birthday order and was sooo relieved that most of the cakes and banana pudding flavors were actually in stock. The pickup times were really clear too, which made the whole thing way easier for me

View More Reviews

Have a question about Magnolia Bakery?
magnoliabakery

Magnolia Bakery Reviews

Coupons & Promo Codes

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.